There was a clue on “Jeopardy!” today that needs some clarification.
![](https://earlthepearl137.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/jimmy-dimes.jpg?w=1024)
The “answer” was “Who is James Buchanan?”
The nickname is correct, but the context is way wrong, as are many details about President Buchanan that have been widely disseminated. Here is the full story as told in “President James Buchanan” a biography by Philip Shriver Klein:
Pages 133-134.
The program of attack on Van Buren presupposed attacks on all his lieutenants. In Pennsylvania there was a very effective propaganda campaign to prove that Buchanan had urged a banking program that would reduce the wages of labor to ten cents a day. “Ten Cent Jimmy,” the pamphlets were labelled. Buchanan, in formal debate, always presented as strongly as he could the case of the opposition, and then proceeded to demolish it systematically by his own arguments. In supporting the Independent Treasury Bill, he had outlined the terrible conditions which would prevail unless banks were reformed and had then gone on to show how much better all would fare under the proposed bill. Senator John Davis of Massachusetts took the first section of this speech, and offered it as Buchanan’s reasons for supporting the Independent Treasury. He took the “ten cents a day” phrase and quoted it out of context, asserting that Buchanan supported the Independent Treasury Bill in the hope that it would reduce wages, destroy banks and deflate property values. Davis’s speeches, when circulated in print, had tremendous political impact.
Forney reported from Pennsylvania: “I do not know when I have been so much disgusted with the course of any political opponent as with that of this Mr. Davis-… He must be either a mere catspaw of others, or a weak, addle-brained man, or a malignant and unscrupulous ruffian… When I see the effect they are making here, by means of his villainous perversion of your intelligible Defence (sic) of the laborer, I cannot but put such a construction upon his unworthy conduct. Why, Sir, they have flooded this county with his so-called Reply to you…. A copy has been sent to nearly every Democrat…. His whole speech is the assumption of the broad ground that the people are ignorant, and unable to discriminate between right and wrong.”
The human mind has not yet discovered the way of counteracting promptly the effect of the bold lie propagated by the prominent man. History is full of pertinent illustrations. If representative government has a nemesis, this is probably it. The “Ten Cent Jimmy” lie seriously weakened Buchanan in Pennsylvania.
Forney proposed that the Democrats “challenge any responsible member of the opposition here to join in the republication of both yours and Davis’ speeches, both of which are to be published correctly and … bound together, and so circulated… If they do not accept, they are down forever.” The opposition did not accept, nor was it down forever. Instead, it proceeded to improve its advantage by reviving the “drop of blood” smear and sending that out with the “Ten Cent Jimmy” pamphlets. Editor Middleton, of the Lancaster Examiner, did much of the printing. He had recently distinguished himself by shooting James Cameron when Cameron came in to beat him up for other lies he had published. Buchanan was for “carrying the war into Carthage,” but his friends advised against it. “It’s only giving tone to falsehoods by heeding them,” wrote Judge Champneys.
Buchanan made several long defensive speeches in the Senate on the “Ten Cent Jimmy” accusations. “If the most artful and unfair man in the world had determined to destroy any public measure,” he asked, “in what manner would he most effectually damn it in public estimation? It would be to enumerate all the terrible consequences which would flow from it, according to the predictions of its enemies, and put them into the mouth of its friends as arguments in its favor. There could not by possibility be any stronger admission of its evil tendency…. This is the ridiculous attitude in which I am placed by the Senator’s speech. If these imputations were well founded, I must be one of the most ferocious men in existence. Destruction must be my delight. No wild agrarian in the country has ever thought of waging such an indiscriminate war against all property, my own among the rest, as that which has been attributed to me by the Senator.” But Buchanan’s exposure of Davis’s fraud proved a futile effort. People found it easier to say “Ten Cent Jimmy” than to read a rebuttal, and the nickname stuck.
Today, we have another Presidential candidate, who delights in bold lies and giving horrible nicknames to his opponents. Nancy Pelosi was called “Crazy Nancy” and “Nervous Nancy.” Hillary Clinton was called “Crooked Hillary.” Even fellow Republicans were verbally attacked if they dared to run against Donald Trump in the primaries. Jeb Bush was “Low Energy Jeb.” Ted Cruz was “Lyin’ Ted.” Well, that one was probably well-deserved, though. Ron DeSantis was “Meatball Ron” or “Ron DeSanctimonious.” Nikki Haley was “Birdbrain.” Marco Rubio was “Little Marco.”
Now, Trump has turned his sights on Joe Biden with nicknames like “Basement Biden” or “Sleepy Joe.” But some people have turned the tables on the orange hate-spewer. Stormy “Horseface” Daniels was one of the star witnesses against him in the case that found him guilty of 34 Felonies. The other star witness against him, Michael Cohen also turned the tables with a nickname of his own for Trump, “Donald Von ShitsinPantz.”
How are we supposed to act when our opponents are cruel or act like a bully? Michelle Obama said, “When someone is cruel or acts like a bully, you don’t stoop to their level. No, our motto is ‘When they go low, we go high.’”
James Buchanan, himself, had advice for settling differences, when he said, “The ballot box is the surest arbiter of disputes among free men.” Keep that in mind this November, and make sure that Donald Trump will no longer be able to bully the country like he tried to do on January 6th, 2021.
![](https://earlthepearl137.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/buchanan-quote.jpg?w=264)
Peace & Love, and all of the above,
Earl